Governance, Risk & Compliance

ISO 27001 vs SOC 2

two very different-shaped proofs of "we take this seriously"

3 min readupdated by Syed Khaleel Ahmed

Customers constantly ask suppliers, "how do we know you handle our data securely?" Two of the most common answers are ISO/IEC 27001 certification and a SOC 2 report. They look similar from a distance and are built differently.

ISO/IEC 27001: a management system, certified

ISO/IEC 27001 is an international standard for an information security management system (ISMS): the organization-wide way you identify risks, choose controls, run them and keep improving.[1] Key features:

  • You define the scope of the ISMS (which parts of the business it covers).
  • You run a risk assessment and decide which controls apply, recorded in a Statement of Applicability. The current edition (2022) lists reference controls in Annex A, in four themes: organizational, people, physical and technological.
  • An independent certification body audits you and issues a certificate, valid for three years with annual surveillance audits.
  • The focus is on the system: leadership commitment, internal audits, management review and continual improvement.

The output is a certificate you can publish, with a stated scope.

SOC 2: an auditor's report on controls

SOC 2 is an attestation framework from the AICPA. An independent CPA firm examines your controls against the Trust Services Criteria and writes a report.[2] The criteria are:

  • Security (always included)
  • Availability
  • Processing integrity
  • Confidentiality
  • Privacy

You and your customers choose which to include. There are two report types:

  • Type I: are the controls designed suitably at a point in time?
  • Type II: did the controls operate effectively over a period (often 6 to 12 months)? Customers usually ask for Type II because it shows consistency.

The output is a detailed report, normally shared under confidentiality, with the auditor's opinion and a description of any exceptions found.

Side by side

ISO/IEC 27001 SOC 2
What it is Certifiable management-system standard Attestation report by a CPA firm
Output Certificate (plus scope statement) Detailed report with opinion
Common in International customers US customers and SaaS vendors
Controls Chosen by you through risk assessment Mapped to selected Trust Services Criteria
Cadence 3-year cycle, annual surveillance Annual report, covering a period

Which one?

It depends mainly on what your customers ask for. Many organizations get both, because a lot of the underlying work (policies, access control, logging, incident response, vendor management) overlaps. A certificate or a report is evidence of a point in time or period, not a guarantee that nothing will go wrong, so read the scope and any exceptions.

Sources

  1. ISO/IEC 27001
  2. AICPA: System and Organization Controls (SOC) suite of services

Test yourself

My notes

Private — saved only on this device, never sent anywhere.