What Actually Happens in an Audit
evidence, sampling, and why auditors ask the same question three ways
An audit is a structured, independent check of whether what an organization says it does matches what it actually does, measured against a set of criteria such as a standard, a law, a contract or its own policies.[2]
Who audits whom
- Internal audit: staff independent of the area audited, giving management assurance.
- External audit: an outside firm, often for certification, regulation or customer assurance.
- Supplier audit: a customer checking its vendor.
Independence matters: the reader must be able to trust that the auditor had no stake in the answer.
The usual flow
- Planning and scoping: agree what is in scope, the criteria, the period and the timeline. Understand the business and its risks.
- Request list: the auditor asks for policies, procedures, listings and evidence.
- Fieldwork: gathering and testing evidence.
- Findings and discussion: the auditor shares observations so facts can be checked before they are final.
- Report: the opinion or results, with findings and management responses.
- Follow-up: confirming that agreed fixes were done.
How auditors gather evidence
Four classic techniques, usually combined:
- Inquiry: asking people how things work.
- Observation: watching a process happen.
- Inspection: examining documents, records and configurations.
- Re-performance: doing the control again themselves to see if they get the same result.
Asking is the weakest evidence on its own, which is why you will be asked to show it.
Sampling
Auditors usually cannot check every case, so they test a sample from a defined population, such as 25 of last year's new starters, and see whether the control worked each time. If the control fails in the sample, they may extend it.
Why the same question comes up three ways
Auditors corroborate: they ask the process owner, look at the policy, and then examine a real record. If all three agree, confidence is high. If they differ, that gap is a finding. It is not a personal attack; it is triangulation.
How a finding is written
A good finding has: the condition (what was found), the criteria (what should be true), the cause, the effect or risk, and a recommendation. Organizations then give a management response with an owner and a date.
Tips for the audited
Be honest, answer the question asked, provide dated evidence, know your own controls, and fix problems before the audit. "We do it, but there is no record" counts as "we do not do it".
Sources
Test yourself
My notes
Private — saved only on this device, never sent anywhere.